Keurig Vs Mr. Coffee: Which Should You Choose?

Just like many other coffee enthusiasts, you are always on the hunt for a great coffee maker, whether for college students, iced coffee, camping & backpacking, or even coffee makers with a grinder, right? You might have tried different coffee makers. But it is now time to weigh between the two top-selling giants: Keurig versus Mr. Coffee. Let’s see which one suits you best.

Settling for the right option can be a daunting task, considering both models are the best in the market. However, this post will give you a vivid comparison between Keurig and Mr. Coffee. That way, you will know the most suitable for you.

Now, pull that chair, and let’s get into it.

Keurig Coffee Maker Overview

Keurig is the original coffee pod maker and an excellent single-serve coffee-making machine. The coffee maker became widely known when it got to the market. The move triggered coffee beans companies to bid for deals that enabled them to turn their coffee into K-cup pods.

Even though the market is full of many single-serve makers, Keurig still stands out as an exceptional and irreplaceable brand.

You can find the Keurig coffee machine and k-cups almost everywhere. Their prices vary depending on the models; some are inexpensive, while others are pricier because of the added features.

Mr. Coffee Overview

Mr. Coffee came into existence in the 1970s, and since that time, the brand has gained popularity globally. The brewer company is in line with the current coffee brewing technologies, offering single-serve coffee machines and large-batch coffee brewers.

What makes Mr. coffee unique is the ability to brew any coffee ground. The coffee makers also come in various price ranges based on their brewing capabilities and functions.

How Do Keurig Coffee Maker and Mr. Coffee Work?

Keurig coffee makers are user-friendly, making them easier to operate. Despite the machine you are using, they are all similar when it comes to operation.

When brewing your coffee using a Keurig, here are a few steps to follow:

  • Add a cup of water to the water reservoir. Though other models have big water reservoirs
  • Put coffee pods in their slot on the brewer.
  • Choose the cup size you want.
  • Finally, press the brew button. If your model gives you the option of the brew strength, remember to select.

When it comes to Mr. Coffee makers, their functioning is similar to most traditional coffee brewers. You can follow these few steps when making your brew using Mr. Coffee:

  • Put water in the water reservoir.
  • Pour up your preferred cup line.
  • Place the coffee filter in the basket.
  • Add on the filter fresh coffee grounds.
  • Choose the brew strength.
  • Touch the brew button.

Key Differences Between The Keurig Coffee Maker And Mr. Coffee

If you have used the two coffee makers, you will realize that there are many differences. In this guide, am going to show you the main differences you will notice between the two.

The Number of Coffee Cups You Can Make at a Time

The Keurig coffee maker is ideal for a single-cup brew. It is the most suitable when you have to get somewhere, and you don’t have time to wait for the whole pot to brew on Mr. Coffee. Also, you might be staying alone, and you don’t need much coffee.

On the other hand, Mr. coffee brewers are most suitable for making multiple coffee cups at a go. Therefore, if you have visitors or don’t want to brew new coffee all the time, then Mr. Coffee will serve you best.

Coffee Maker Grinds

You use coffee pods when brewing with the Keurig coffee maker. Again, if you decide to use reusable coffee pods, there will be no harm.

With Mr. coffee, you can use any coffee grind according to your preference. The coffee grind texture does not matter.

Build Quality and Design

Both brands have a perfect reputation as far as build quality is concerned. But which one receives the highest score when it comes to the single-serve model?

Keurig’s single-serve premium finish speaks durability. The coffee brewer has a streamlined design without any detectable small parts. That makes it easy to maintain.

Besides, there are minimal chances for breakages. 

On the other hand, Mr. coffee’s single-cup has a streamlined design similar to the Keurig. However, it has several buttons and some crevices and nooks. That indicates the brewer needs more maintenance.

On overall construction, Mr. coffee has a sturdy flipside, while the Keurig seems a bit flimsy. With this, I would say Mr. coffee scores higher based on durability and overall build quality.

Price of Coffee Maker

How much money do you wish to spend on a coffee maker? If you need to save as much as you can, Mr. coffee brewers will be the best option. That’s because they come in budget-friendly sizes. Besides, their single cup makers are relatively cheaper than the Keurig single-cup brewers.

If money is not a problem and you need the most convenient coffee brewer, Keurig models are what you need. They have a wide selection of high-quality coffee-making machines. Besides, with their dual coffee maker, you won’t waste time on the traditional brewing techniques.

Versatility of Keurig Coffee Maker

Keurig coffee maker has many fascinating features. Energy efficiency is one of them. After brewing your cup of coffee, the coffee maker turns itself off, thus, saving on energy.

But you will agree with me that versatility does not only involve energy efficiency. There are other considerations like compatibility and flexibility. A majority of k-cups are compatible with the Keurig coffee brewer. Therefore, with divergent tastes, you will still have your cup of coffee.

In addition, the Keurig single-serve is travel-friendly because of its compatibility with the average travel bag. You remove the bottom drip tray, and it fits in your travel bag.

Just like the Keurig, Mr. coffee is compatible with a majority of k-cups as well. But the brewer is not as versatile as its Keurig counterpart.

Mr. coffee brewer makes only one type of coffee for the entire pot, whereas the Keurig coffee maker gives you a chance to choose the coffee type you need. You can even opt for hot cocoa or tea as a substitute for coffee.


If convenience is what you need, go for the Keurig single-cup models. They are easy to clean too. Now, in terms of coffee flavor flexibility, the Keurig multi-cup reservoir will do you good.

But still, if you are a traditional coffee brewing fan and love Keurig models, choose the dual coffee brewer.

Mr. Coffee, on the other hand, is convenient if you prefer a smaller pot and don’t like the single-cup coffee maker. You can buy the 5-cup mini brewer for a small household. However, if the family has multiple coffee lovers, the 12-cup coffee maker will meet your needs.

Again, if you love the k-cup convenience but prefer Mr. Coffee to Keurig, feel free to break into the coffee pods world with the k-cup brewers.

Ease of Use

Both two coffee machines are easy to use. Therefore, beginners can operate with a lot of ease. When you look at the two, Mr. coffee has some extra buttons as compared to Keurig. But that doesn’t mean that it is difficult for a beginner to operate. They are simple and easy to master.

I cannot also say that Keurig brewer is hard to use. Anyway, with the fewer buttons, you can’t find any other machine simpler than that.

Cleaning and Maintenance

With any coffee machine, proper maintenance is vital to guarantee its durability and perfect functioning.

I know you love Keurig for its convenience. But when it comes to cleaning, the brewer is a bit notorious.

The good thing is that the brewer is less messy while in use. However, you must carry out regular descaling in its inside parts for continued proper functioning.

 Also, regular cleaning help reduce the chances of mineral and mold build-up. A majority of the k-cups cannot be recycled. So, you have to remove them when cleaning.

On the contrary, Mr. Coffee brewer is slightly messier than Keurig but easy to clean. The simplest way out is to ensure that you thoroughly rinse the carafe after use and allow it to dry.

For deeper cleaning, you pour a cleaning solution into the brewer’s empty reservoir. You can use white vinegar. Put a clean filter in the filter basket and switch on the machine. Rinse thoroughly, and that’s it. You are ready to brew another tasty cup of coffee.

Keurig Coffee Maker Vs Mr. Coffee: Which Should You Choose?

When it comes to settling for the most suitable, it is a personal decision to make. That’s because both coffee makers are the best and top-selling in the market today. Besides, some features make each brewer unique on its own.

Nevertheless, several factors can guide you on which way to go. Allow me to simplify it for you below.

The Keurig coffee maker will be the most suitable :

  • If you want a quicker cup of coffee.
  • When you are looking for an easy-to-use and convenient brewer.
  • You want a machine with a variety of drinks such as hot cocoa and tea apart from coffee.
  • If you want a brewer that is less messy when preparing your coffee.
  • You don’t mind about the price.

Mr. Coffee brewer will stand out to be the best if:

  • You are working on a budget, and you need a less expensive brewer.
  • When you will be making multiple coffee cups at the same time.
  • You want to be free to use any form of coffee grounds.
  • You want a coffee maker you can clean easily.


With all said, I will be glad if this post helps you make a well-informed decision on whether to buy Keurig or Mr. Coffee. Each brand has several models available in the market. So, you can never miss your spot. Again, your preferences and budget speak it all. I hope you enjoy your cup of coffee from the new brewer you will purchase.